x
Breaking News
More () »

Bill dictates hunting, not sterilization to control deer populations

The bill targets the city of Ann Arbor, the only city that has been using sterilization program to help manage the deer herd in the city.
Credit: Michigan DNR
Undated photo of a deer in the woods.

LANSING — The Michigan House of Representatives gave final passage Thursday to a bill that prohibits communities from adopting deer sterilization programs to limit growing deer populations in their towns.

The bill, which passed on a 67-42 vote shortly before 2 a.m. Thursday during the lame duck legislative session, targets the city of Ann Arbor, the only city that has been using sterilization program to help manage the deer herd in the city.

For the past 2 years, the city of Ann Arbor has been using a two-pronged approach to stabilize the deer population: using sharp shooters to kill the herds in open areas of the city and capturing and sterilizing does in densely populated neighborhoods.

Last year, the city sterilized 54 deer and hired sharpshooters to kill 100 more. So far this year, the city has budgeted $370,000 for the two programs to cull the herd. The sterilization is a process that takes about two hours and the deer are taken back to the area where they were captured.

Ann Arbor will be able to finish out its three-year program, but no other town will be able to get a permit from the state to pursue a sterilization program.

More on freep.com:

Michigan State Police trooper nearly collides with group of deer crossing road

Election newsletter: Lame duck legislature, fireworks

Ban on prescribing abortion drugs by teleconference is made permanent

But the sterilization programs offended some lawmakers, who felt that employing hunters to cull the herds was a much more effective program.

"Why do we need deer sterilization in the first place when we have sportsmen who are fully capable of managing our deer species," said Rep. Triston Cole, R-Mancelona, who sponsored the legislation. "This is a wonderful opportunity for urban residents to learn about quality deer management and the benefits of hunting to the entire state."

The bill would prohibit the Department of Natural Resources from issuing sterilization permits until at least April 1, 2022, while the Natural Resources Commission studied different programs, including sterilization, to control deer herds.

In the meantime, the bill passed by the House allows a city to adopt a firearm hunting distance requirement that is shorter than the current law that mandates at least 150-yard distance that a hunter has to stay away from an occupied building, house or barn without the permission of the owner, renter or occupant of the property.

The bill — HB 5321 — now goes to Gov. Rick Snyder to sign or veto.

Contact Kathleen Gray: 313-223-4430, kgray99@freepress.com or on Twitter @michpoligal

Before You Leave, Check This Out